Mar 182015

Master Graphic liquid marker eyeliner

Maybelline claims:

Automatically draw the boldest line with the sharpest edge.
Pitch black finish.
All day wear.


Maybelline New York Master Graphic liquid marker eyeliner

Maybelline New York Master Graphic liquid marker eyeliner

[My opinion]

I had a love-hate relationship with this liner. It started badly – very weak pigmentation did not allow me to draw a decent line. But after some time, it started to work. Suddenly it became possible to draw a nice line, literally in a couple of strokes; fast and easy. It seams that this liner needs some time to work, because at the beginning the applicator is dry and needs time that liquid formula touches the applicator. But, it stays unstable, so the problems still occur.

This is not my first liquid pen eyeliner and I must admit that I never had the best experiences with them. What they also have in common is unpleasant scent. This combination did not win me over, and I think that it is better to stick with the classic markers/pens, as well as the classic liquid liners. The good thing is that when it is in its best shape, it is possible to quickly draw a precise line. It is a shame that it is not waterproof, because thick lines need a stable formula.

Net weight: 2.5 ml | 0.08 fl.oz.
Price: £5.99 | $6.94


Maybelline New York Master Graphic liquid marker eyelinerUsed products: Maybelline New York Master Graphic liquid marker eyeliner, Eylure N°035 lashes, Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow Pomade Blonde, MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Soft Ochre & Look by Bipa kajal night dust



Colossal Go Extreme! Leather black mascara

Maybelline claims:

Our first mascara with a superloading wand adds an extra shot of volume onto our biggest brush. Blackout pigments – Bold, Leather Black intensity!
20x Collagen vs Colossal Original!
Up to 16x bolder looking lashes vs Bare lashes!

Maybelline New York Colossal Go Extreme! Leather black mascara

Maybelline New York Colossal Go Extreme! Leather black mascara


[My opinion]

This mascara is the same as the previous Colossal Go Extreme! mascara; the names of the shades are the only real difference. The first one is Very black, and this one is Leather black. They have the same brush, handle and formula, and besides the name and the color of packaging, there is no difference. In fact, the difference in the color is so slight that practically it doesn’t exist. They provide the same effect, and my opinion about it you can find in the post about Colossal Go Extreme! Very black mascara.

Net weight: 9.5 ml | 0.32 fl.oz.
Price: £6.99 | approx. $10.30


PR samples

Do you use Maybelline mascaras and eyeliners? Have you tried these?



  34 Responses to “Maybelline New York Master Graphic liquid marker eyeliner & Colossal Go Extreme! Leather black mascara”

  1. the eyeliner looks like a thick marker o.0 and it isn’t waterproof?! that’s quite a shame.

  2. I never really had a great experience with felt tip type eyeliners either. They tend to not be opaque and dry out quickly.

  3. I would prefer the eyeliner pen with straight thin tip. Great review.

  4. i haven’t tried this eyeliner… the tip looks interesting but sad to know that its not waterproof!

  5. I haven’t tried either of these, but the current liquid eyeliner is quite good actually! thank you for the review :) x

  6. I’ve been looking for a really fast and simple liner.. I’m so lazy **hides face** I’ll try this on for size and see if it’s for me .. Thanks for sharing xx

  7. I hope the mascara can seriously help my asian eyelash to curl =) You look great!!

  8. The black eye liner is so bold and great!
    and i love the colossal mascara as well <3

  9. I love that eyeliner, seems like it is travel-friendly and easy to apply as well.

  10. This looks amazing. I’ve been looking for a new liner. I think I’ve found one.

  11. wow, both of them looks innovative specially the liner. sad that I haven’t seen them yet in Malaysia :(

  12. Both products are nice but the eyeliner is a little bit off for me :/ thank you for your honest reviews!

  13. I really want to try the graphic liner. Since i saw it on maybelline IG… however, i haven’t seen it in stores.

  14. R u serious, such awesomeness has a flaw? not waterproof. Thats just plain silly isn’t it. Otherwise it looks spectacular.

  15. The eyeliner looks similar to the Benefits push up eyeliner. Thanks for sharing

  16. I really like the eyeliner’s tip, i think it works for a great cat eye or winged tip!


  17. I’ve got these products to review myself! Going by your verdict, I am really interested to see how they work for me :D

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



:) ;) :x :* :> :p B) ;;) @) =P~ 8-> =D> :-h ^#(^ ^:)^ [-o< :-S :-O 8-| :( :(( (*) more »

Web Analytics